You've cut the cord (or never had it), and now you need a way to watch Netflix, Hulu, YouTube, and the dozen other streaming services competing for your attention. Enter the streaming device.
But which one? Roku, Fire TV, Apple TV, Chromecast — they all claim to be the best. Here's an honest comparison to help you decide.
The Contenders
Roku
The original streaming device company. Options range from the basic Roku Express ($30) to the premium Roku Ultra ($100).
Amazon Fire TV
Amazon's streaming platform. Available as Fire TV Stick ($40), Fire TV Stick 4K ($50), and Fire TV Cube ($140).
Apple TV
Apple's premium option. Apple TV HD ($150) and Apple TV 4K ($130-$180).
Google Chromecast
Google's approach to streaming. Chromecast with Google TV ($30-$50) is the current model.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Roku | Fire TV | Apple TV | Chromecast |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $30 | $40 | $130 | $30 |
| 4K Option | $50 | $50 | $130 | $50 |
| Voice Assistant | Roku Voice | Alexa | Siri | |
| App Selection | Excellent | Excellent | Good | Good |
| Interface | Neutral | Amazon-focused | Apple-focused | Google-focused |
| Best For | Most people | Alexa users | Apple households | Google users |
Roku: The Switzerland of Streaming
Strengths
Platform agnostic: Roku doesn't have a dog in the streaming wars. The interface treats Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney+, and every other service equally. No service gets preferential treatment.
Enormous app selection: If a streaming service exists, it's probably on Roku. Even niche services and free ad-supported channels are well represented.
Simple interface: Roku's grid of apps is straightforward. No learning curve, minimal distractions.
Universal search: Search for a movie, and Roku shows you where it's available (including free options) across all your apps.
Affordable: Entry-level Roku Express is very cheap, and even the best models are reasonably priced.
Weaknesses
Hardware is basic: Lower-end Rokus can feel sluggish compared to premium devices.
Remote is simple: Basic remote works fine, but lacks some features competitors offer.
No ecosystem perks: Unlike Apple TV or Fire TV, there's no larger ecosystem integration.
Best For
- People who want simplicity
- Households with multiple streaming services
- Budget-conscious buyers
- Anyone who doesn't want a device pushing a particular service
Our Pick
Roku Streaming Stick 4K ($50) — Best balance of price and performance.
Fire TV: For Alexa Households
Strengths
Deep Alexa integration: If you have Echo devices, Fire TV fits right in. Voice control is excellent, and you can ask Alexa to control your TV from anywhere in the house.
Good app selection: Nearly as comprehensive as Roku.
Amazon Prime integration: If you're a Prime member, the Fire TV experience is tailored for Prime Video.
Affordable: Competitive pricing with Roku.
Live TV integration: The Fire TV interface can integrate live TV from supported services nicely.
Weaknesses
Amazon-heavy interface: The home screen pushes Amazon content. Prime Video gets prominent placement, and you'll see ads for content Amazon wants you to buy/rent.
Sponsored content: The home screen includes ads, even on the device you paid for.
Can feel cluttered: The interface has a lot going on compared to Roku's simplicity.
Best For
- Amazon Prime members
- Alexa smart home users
- People who want voice control throughout the house
Our Pick
Fire TV Stick 4K ($50) — Good performance, 4K support, affordable.
Apple TV: The Premium Option
Strengths
Best-in-class hardware: Apple TV 4K is fast, responsive, and buttery smooth. No lag, no waiting for apps to load.
Excellent remote: The Siri Remote is a proper remote with good ergonomics, a clickpad, and voice control.
Privacy focused: Apple doesn't use your viewing habits to sell ads. What you watch stays private.
Apple ecosystem integration: AirPlay for easy casting, Apple TV app syncs across devices, Apple Fitness+ integration, seamless handoff.
Gaming capable: Apple Arcade works well, and you can use PlayStation or Xbox controllers.
Picture quality: Apple TV consistently produces the best picture quality with proper HDR handling.
Weaknesses
Price: Significantly more expensive than competitors.
Apple-centric: Best experience if you're already in the Apple ecosystem.
Smaller app library: Most major apps are available, but some niche services are missing.
Interface can be confusing: The focus on the Apple TV app can be disorienting if you just want to open Netflix.
Best For
- Apple households (iPhone, iPad, Mac users)
- People who prioritize picture quality
- Privacy-conscious viewers
- Anyone who wants premium hardware
Our Pick
Apple TV 4K (2022) — If you're buying Apple TV, get the 4K version. The price difference is worth it.
Chromecast with Google TV: For Google Users
Strengths
Google integration: Works seamlessly with Google Assistant, Google Photos, YouTube, etc.
Good interface: Google TV interface is well-designed with personalized recommendations.
Affordable: The 4K model is competitively priced.
Casting: Easy to cast from any Android device or Chrome browser.
Profile support: Multiple users can have personalized recommendations.
Weaknesses
Storage limitations: The device has limited storage, which can be an issue if you install many apps.
Google-focused: Recommendations lean toward Google services (YouTube, YouTube TV).
Dongle form factor: Hangs from your TV, which can be awkward depending on your setup.
Remote battery life: Some users report frequent battery replacements.
Best For
- Google Assistant users
- Android phone households
- YouTube-heavy viewers
- People who cast from phones frequently
Our Pick
Chromecast with Google TV 4K ($50) — Good value, good features.
Smart TV Apps: Why You Still Might Want a Streaming Device
Many TVs have streaming apps built in. Why buy a separate device?
Reasons to Use Built-in Apps
- One less device and remote
- Already there, no extra cost
- Fine for casual viewing
Reasons to Add a Streaming Device
- Faster interface: Built-in TV apps are often slow and clunky
- Better updates: TV manufacturers stop updating apps; streaming devices get updates for years
- More app selection: Not all apps are available on all TV platforms
- Consistent experience: Use the same device/interface on every TV in your house
- Better voice assistants: TV built-in assistants are usually worse than Alexa/Siri/Google
Generally, a dedicated streaming device provides a better experience than built-in apps, unless you have a very recent, high-end TV.
Setup Considerations
WiFi Connection
All streaming devices need WiFi. For best results:
- Place your router reasonably close to the TV
- Use 5GHz band for streaming (less congestion, better bandwidth)
- Consider Ethernet if available (some devices support it with adapters)
If you have WiFi issues, a streaming device won't fix them. Start with your network.
HDMI Ports
Streaming devices use HDMI. Make sure you have a free port. If you're mounting a TV, plan where the device will go and how visible cables will be.
Power
Most streaming devices are powered by USB. Many TVs have USB ports that can power them. The convenience depends on whether your TV USB stays powered when the TV is off.
Alternatively, use the included power adapter plugged into an outlet.
4K and HDR
If you have a 4K TV, get a 4K streaming device to take full advantage. Also check for:
- HDR support (HDR10, Dolby Vision)
- HDMI 2.0 or 2.1 port on your TV
- Sufficient internet speed (25+ Mbps for 4K)
Our Recommendation
For most people: Roku Streaming Stick 4K or Chromecast with Google TV. Best balance of price, features, and ease of use.
For Amazon households: Fire TV Stick 4K if you're deep in the Alexa ecosystem.
For Apple households: Apple TV 4K if you have iPhones, iPads, and value the premium experience.
What We Do
At Finally Fixed Home Services, we can help with:
- Streaming device setup and configuration
- Mounting devices cleanly behind TVs
- Optimizing WiFi for streaming
- Setting up multiple TVs with consistent streaming experiences
- Integrating streaming devices with smart home systems
Contact us or call/text 720-933-3501 if you need help getting your streaming setup dialed in.
Related Posts: